العربية
☽

The Academic Supply Line
to Israel's Military Industry

0
universities and institutes
0
countries
0
EU-funded projects
+
million dollars in defence funding to a single institute

Arabic Post traced the paths of cooperation between American and European universities and institutes and Israeli military industry companies, along with academic institutions tied to Israel's security establishment, by reviewing research partnerships, applied projects, and official academic and funding documents.

The monitoring drew on university websites, European and American project records, descriptive pages for joint projects and programmes, and material published by the Israeli companies themselves.

The investigation records how the documents reveal that, in some cases, the cooperation goes beyond the general academic frame to touch on security technology and dual-use systems that serve Israeli military industries.

It also shows that this cooperation between universities and Israeli entities does not always run through direct academic agreements alone, but also through technical partnerships, training laboratories, project sponsorship, and participation in research consortia that include Israeli entities active in the defence, space and cybersecurity sectors.

While this overlap is not automatic proof of direct military use in every project, the investigation does record a documented convergence between Western academic research and an Israeli system in which universities and Israeli military industry companies — both army-owned and private — intersect within a single structure serving Israeli security, industry, and technological and military superiority.

How the link works

Partnerships between universities and Israeli military industry companies

The partnerships between American and European universities and Israeli military manufacturing companies include:

Names inside the campus
Jeff Crystal

University of Central Florida documents confirm that Jeff Crystal of Elbit Systems of America served as an adviser at UCF's College of Optics.

Stephen Cambone

Stephen Cambone: a board member of Elbit Systems of America; he works as an independent consultant, and his biography states that he is a member of the advisory board of the Volgenau School at George Mason University and an adjunct professor at Johns Hopkins University.

Marios Savvides

Marios Savvides: director of the Biometrics Center at Carnegie Mellon University, who joined Oosto/AnyVision as chief AI scientist in 2021.

Robert D. (Bob) Johnson

Robert D. (Bob) Johnson: he sits on the dean's council of the W.P. Carey School of Business at Arizona State University, the board of trustees of Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University, and the business advisory council at the University of Arizona — and is a board member of Elbit Systems of America.

And while this is not automatic proof of direct military use, a documented overlap can be traced between Western academic research and an Israeli system in which universities and Israeli military industry companies — both army-owned and private — intersect.

Where does the expertise come from?

Each arc represents a country whose universities appear inside projects or partnerships with Israeli military industries. Arc thickness follows the number of universities. Hover over any node for details.

Academic source Destination: Israel

Swipe the graphic horizontally to see it in full →

The map illustrates documented relationships; it does not depict physical transfer routes. Figures = number of universities recorded in each country.

Universities map

24
European universities across 11 countries
15
universities and institutes in the United States
7
universities in the United Kingdom — the highest European presence
4
recurring Israeli entities: Elbit · IAI · Rafael · the army ministry

The leading European universities cooperating with Israeli military industry companies

Official European research and innovation project databases show that a number of universities in European countries took part in consortia that included Israeli military industry companies such as Elbit Systems, Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) and Rafael — and, in at least one case, the Israeli army ministry itself.

CORDIS is the official portal of the European Commission, run by the Publications Office of the European Union. It serves as the public database and primary source for all results of research and innovation projects funded by the EU.

The data reveals that some European universities entered into documented research, engineering and security partnerships with Israeli defence companies, or with official bodies tied to the Israeli military structure.

The sensitivity of these links lies in the fact that the European framework governing Horizon Europe funding states explicitly that funded activities must have an exclusive focus on civil applications — while at the same time clarifying that the participation of defence companies or military organisations is not automatically excluded, so long as the research activities themselves are framed and managed within that civilian ceiling. (screenshot).

The European Commission later also acknowledged that the outputs of some projects may evolve, after the project's lifetime ends, into technologies with dual-use potential. (screenshot).

Which projects did European universities take part in alongside Israeli defence companies?

Swipe the graphic horizontally to see it in full →

First: The railway protection project (PROTECTRAIL)

It is a major research initiative funded by the European Union, aimed at building an integrated, comprehensive security system to protect Europe's railway infrastructure.

This project (2010–2014) is one of the largest security projects in the history of the European Union, with a budget of roughly 20 million euros, and it brought together a large consortium of 29 partners from a range of sectors.

Elbit Systems took part — through its Israeli branch and its Italian branch — as a principal technology supplier to the project, contributing its expertise in surveillance systems, command and control (C4I), and advanced protection technologies.

On the academic and research side, the project brought in several prestigious research centres, universities and educational institutions to ensure scientific and technical viability, most notably:

Participating institutionCountry
University of NamurBelgiumBelgium
Kingston UniversityUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom

Second: The OUTCOME project

A European project that aimed to train early-stage researchers and develop solutions for analysing and designing aerospace and defence structures exposed to extreme thermal and mechanical loading conditions.

According to the European Commission's project page, the project coordinator is Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, joined — alongside European institutions and companies — by France's University of Lorraine and Israel's Technion.

What stands out in the project, which ran between 2016 and 2019 and which on its face was research cooperation in solid mechanics while its actual field of application was aerospace and defence structures, is the role of Israel's Rafael as an executing participant — reflecting a European model that permits practical intersections between university research and industrial structures tied to the defence sector, even when European funding does not go directly to the military company itself.

Third: A space technology project (QI2S)

A European–Israeli project in space technology whose aim was to narrow the gap between capturing a satellite image and turning it into usable information, by moving part of the "analytical intelligence" onto the satellite itself.

According to the official record in CORDIS, Israel's Elbit Systems coordinated the project, which ran between 2013 and 2015, while Germany's Technische Universität Braunschweig stood out as the only university body within a consortium of six partners from four countries — one dominated by an industrial-technical character rather than a purely academic one.

Fourth: Re-engineering the aircraft design cycle — CRESCENDO

A major European project that sought to re-engineer the aircraft design cycle through a collaborative digital environment built on simulation and data exchange between manufacturers, suppliers and universities.

According to the CORDIS database, the project brought together 59 partners from 13 countries and ran between 2009 and 2012, among them European academic institutions — reflecting the breadth of European university presence within a consortium led by the major aviation industry.

But the politically most sensitive angle lies in the presence of Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) inside the project — not as a marginal name, but as an Israeli industrial partner formally listed in the consortium and allocated 258,500 euros of the European contribution.

Final report documents show that the company's role was not administrative or nominal, but directly technical.

The European universities that took part in the project are:

UniversityCountry
Brandenburg University of Technology Cottbus–SenftenbergGermanyGermany
Cranfield UniversityUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom
National Institute of Applied Sciences, ToulouseFranceFrance
Linköping UniversitySwedenSweden
Luleå University of TechnologySwedenSweden
Politecnico di TorinoItalyItaly
Queen's University BelfastUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom
University of SalentoItalyItaly
University of SouthamptonUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom
University of CambridgeUnited KingdomUnited Kingdom
University of LimerickIrelandIreland

Fifth: The INAFLOWT project

A project under the European Union's Horizon 2020 programme — specifically within the Clean Sky 2 initiative — aimed at developing advanced air-flow control technologies to improve the aerodynamic efficiency of commercial aircraft.

According to the CORDIS database, the project, which ran between 2017 and 2020, included Germany's University of Stuttgart alongside Tel Aviv University and the Israeli space company IAI, which took part to provide industrial and technical expertise in designing, building and testing the models.

Sixth: The SecureGas project

A project focused on protecting the European gas network from physical and cyber threats. According to the official CORDIS page, Riga Technical University is among the participants, alongside Israel's Elbit Systems, which for its part provided expertise and solutions related to the cybersecurity of industrial control systems — that is, in the sensitive zone where digital security meets the operation of gas infrastructure.

Seventh: The rail and metro protection project

A European project under Horizon 2020 focused on protecting rail and metro networks from cyber and physical threats, particularly where digital attacks intersect with the operational infrastructure of transport.

The project began in 2020 and ended in 2022, and according to CORDIS, the University of Reading and Newcastle University from Britain appear, along with Spain's Universidad Miguel Hernández de Elche (UMH) and Finland's Laurea University of Applied Sciences.

And although the project aims to develop methods and systems to improve safety in intercity rail and urban metro transport, Israel's Elbit Systems emerged as a partner in it.

Eighth: The underwater security project

An EU-funded project in the field of protecting and securing maritime areas and ports, aimed at developing a prototype system to protect ships, ports and marine, river and coastal infrastructure from threats coming from underwater.

Taking part in the project, which began in October 2023 and ends in September 2026, are the two Greek universities of West Attica and the Hellenic Mediterranean, alongside the Israeli army ministry, which was a contributing body within the project.

Alongside the Israeli army ministry, the role of the Israeli defence company Rafael stood out as a technology provider, with Tel Aviv University researching underwater acoustics and training.

European distribution · 24 universities in 11 countries

Swipe the graphic horizontally to see it in full →

Circle size follows the number of universities in each country. Hover over a circle to see the university names.
The American track

Documenting the cooperation between American universities and Israeli defence companies

1. Direct research funding and projects with military applications

+11 million dollars
in direct defence funding from the Israeli Ministry of Defense to MIT since 2015
1.6 million dollars
for 2023 alone

The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) has received direct defence funding from the Israeli Ministry of Defense exceeding 11 million dollars since 2015, of which more than 1.6 million dollars was allocated for 2023 alone. (screenshot).

These funds support projects with clear military applications such as autonomous robot swarms, pursuit-and-evasion strategy algorithms, persistent underwater surveillance, and quantum magnetometry over optical fibre.

Israel's Elbit is also a member of the institute's Industrial Liaison Program.

2. Institutional partnerships and industrial relations

Cornell University / Cornell Tech

it began its institutional partnership with the Technion in 2011 to establish a technology institute in New York.

Documents show that this partnership is tied to the Israeli military-industrial complex indirectly, with the Technion's industry guidance document describing its graduates as having contributed to "the establishment and defence of the State of Israel" and presenting industrial and research relations with IAI and Rafael.

The University of Texas at Dallas

it has an indirect financial and institutional relationship, in addition to academic cooperation with Israeli technology bodies since 2007.

The University of Texas at Arlington (UTA)

it has a direct link through research funding from Elbit Systems of America, in addition to a student training track, documented in faculty files from 2021 to 2023 at least.

For example, the profile page of Dr. David Wetz at the University of Texas at Arlington confirms that he has a project funded by Elbit Systems.

Elbit Systems also indicates that it took part in university career fairs in 2022, among them the University of Texas at Arlington, and that it was seeking to fill 24 internship positions.

The University of Central Florida (UCF)

the website of the university's computer vision programme states that its computer vision research centre has industrial partners, among them Elbit Systems, which provides research funding and training opportunities for students.

An additional document from the 2019 annual CREOL report lists Elbit Systems among the industrial partners.

3. Cyber training and simulation centres (the Cyberbit Range platform)

Several universities have relied on the "Cyberbit Range" training platform, developed by Cyberbit — a spin-off of Israel's Elbit Systems — to train students and professionals in cybersecurity and attack simulation. Among these universities:

  • Purdue University: it adopted the platform in 2019 to train students and professionals in simulating cyber attacks.
  • Regent University: it established a cyber training and simulation centre on campus in cooperation with Cyberbit Range.
  • Yeshiva University (Katz School): its security operations centre uses the Cyberbit range as a live training environment for students and researchers in 2023.
  • The University of Maine at Augusta: in 2019 it announced the establishment of a centre based on Cyberbit Range technology, integrating its scenarios into the cybersecurity curriculum.
  • Metropolitan State University (Minnesota): Elbit Systems of America announced a partnership in 2017 to establish a cyber training and simulation centre using the Cyberbit Range platform.
  • Miami Dade College: its cybersecurity centre includes an advanced Cyber Range "designed by Cyberbit".

4. Technical cooperation in industry, aviation and surveillance

2016 / NDSU

North Dakota State University (NDSU): in 2016 it took part in a project to test a Hermes 450 unmanned aerial vehicle manufactured by Elbit Systems, for agricultural research purposes.

2022 / Texas A&M

Texas A&M University: Elbit Systems took part in 2022 in sponsoring the "Texas Manufacturing Renaissance" conference in partnership with the SecureAmerica Institute at Texas A&M. The conference focused on strengthening supply chains and domestic manufacturing in the defence and space sectors, alongside developing workforce skills and closing training gaps in the manufacturing sector.

2021 / Carnegie Mellon

Carnegie Mellon University: in November 2021 the university's CyLab Biometrics Center cooperated with Oosto (the new name of AnyVision), a company that provides military surveillance technology in the West Bank, to conduct early research on object and behaviour recognition. The centre's director also joined the company as chief AI scientist.

Where the cooperation concentrates

Fields of cooperation between Western universities and Israeli military manufacturing companies

The preceding data shows that cooperation between American universities and Israeli defence companies is concentrated in the following fields:

01
Cybersecurity, training and simulation.
02
Military research, robotics and artificial intelligence.
03
Unmanned aerial vehicles and civil and military applications.
04
Computer vision, surveillance and biometrics.
05
Defence manufacturing and workforce training.
06
Indirect institutional and financial partnerships.

What do Israeli military industry companies gain from partnerships with universities?

Israeli arms companies and the army benefit from these partnerships in several ways:

01
Technology transfer and development

research partnerships give Israel access to academic innovations and original research that accelerate the development of its military technologies.

For example, the cooperation in the QI2S project brought together an Elbit-led consortium to develop high-performance satellite image processing systems.

02
Testing and evaluating systems

taken together, the projects provide important field trials in European laboratories.

As with the TASS project for testing airport surveillance systems, which tested its technologies at Heathrow and London and at airports in Israel and Greece, helping Elbit and others to evaluate their products under real conditions.

03
Training and academic recognition

Elbit Systems' participation in academic training centres (such as the cyber centre at MSU) expands its capacity to train its own engineers. Academic partnerships also lend "legitimacy" to its products through the publication of studies associated with them.

04
Boosting sales and reputation

research partnerships with prestigious universities give Israeli defence companies an opportunity to showcase their capabilities inside internationally recognised academic and technological environments, and to use these partnerships in presenting themselves to defence funders and contracting bodies.

This appears, for example, in Elbit Systems' announcement of its partnership with Stanford University and Physical Sciences Inc. under the DARPA ENVision programme, where the company presented this cooperation as a factor strengthening its ability to deliver an advanced night-vision solution for American soldiers.

The impact

How do these relations affect conflicts and security policy?

Western universities' support for Israeli projects is reflected in a number of geopolitical dimensions:

01
Strengthening Israeli capabilities

official documents revealed that Israeli defence companies took part with Western universities in projects developing advanced technologies in sensing and space, unmanned aerial vehicles, and maritime security.

02
Security networking and international legitimacy

academic and research partnerships give Israeli defence companies a presence inside internationally recognised scientific and industrial networks, which can strengthen their technical image before funders and contracting bodies.

Organisations such as Statewatch have raised the problem of Israeli security participation in European civilian projects, arguing that EU funding of projects including Israeli military companies ties European research programmes to the Israeli military industry. Similar questions have been raised inside the European Parliament about granting European money to Israeli military companies and the Israeli Ministry of Defense through the Horizon Europe programmes.

A previous Arabic Post investigation revealed that the Gaza war contributed to the global sales of Israel's Elbit Systems, and that sales in European countries saw a marked rise.